{"componentChunkName":"component---node-modules-narative-gatsby-theme-novela-src-templates-article-template-tsx","path":"/covid-19-open-spaces:-numbers-and-reality-in-nyc","result":{"data":{"allSite":{"edges":[{"node":{"siteMetadata":{"name":"MIT Civic Data Design Lab"}}}]}},"pageContext":{"article":{"id":"185b6f9c-f595-5e66-b928-e44fb5be0ba4","slug":"/covid-19-open-spaces:-numbers-and-reality-in-nyc","secret":false,"title":"COVID-19 Open Spaces: Numbers and Reality in NYC","author":"Laura Kim","date":"August 14th, 2020","dateForSEO":"2020-08-14T00:00:00.000Z","timeToRead":5,"excerpt":"Access to open space is an urban luxury. Cities' makeup prioritizes buildings rather than vast, green space in order to ensure density. But…","canonical_url":null,"subscription":true,"body":"function _extends() { _extends = Object.assign || function (target) { for (var i = 1; i < arguments.length; i++) { var source = arguments[i]; for (var key in source) { if (Object.prototype.hasOwnProperty.call(source, key)) { target[key] = source[key]; } } } return target; }; return _extends.apply(this, arguments); }\n\nfunction _objectWithoutProperties(source, excluded) { if (source == null) return {}; var target = _objectWithoutPropertiesLoose(source, excluded); var key, i; if (Object.getOwnPropertySymbols) { var sourceSymbolKeys = Object.getOwnPropertySymbols(source); for (i = 0; i < sourceSymbolKeys.length; i++) { key = sourceSymbolKeys[i]; if (excluded.indexOf(key) >= 0) continue; if (!Object.prototype.propertyIsEnumerable.call(source, key)) continue; target[key] = source[key]; } } return target; }\n\nfunction _objectWithoutPropertiesLoose(source, excluded) { if (source == null) return {}; var target = {}; var sourceKeys = Object.keys(source); var key, i; for (i = 0; i < sourceKeys.length; i++) { key = sourceKeys[i]; if (excluded.indexOf(key) >= 0) continue; target[key] = source[key]; } return target; }\n\n/* @jsx mdx */\nvar _frontmatter = {\n  \"title\": \"COVID-19 Open Spaces: Numbers and Reality in NYC\",\n  \"author\": \"Laura Kim\",\n  \"date\": \"2020-08-14T00:00:00.000Z\",\n  \"tags\": [\"Covid\", \"Mapping\"],\n  \"hero\": \"images/maps2.png\"\n};\n\nvar makeShortcode = function makeShortcode(name) {\n  return function MDXDefaultShortcode(props) {\n    console.warn(\"Component \" + name + \" was not imported, exported, or provided by MDXProvider as global scope\");\n    return mdx(\"div\", props);\n  };\n};\n\nvar layoutProps = {\n  _frontmatter: _frontmatter\n};\nvar MDXLayout = \"wrapper\";\nreturn function MDXContent(_ref) {\n  var components = _ref.components,\n      props = _objectWithoutProperties(_ref, [\"components\"]);\n\n  return mdx(MDXLayout, _extends({}, layoutProps, props, {\n    components: components,\n    mdxType: \"MDXLayout\"\n  }), mdx(\"p\", null, \"Access to open space is an urban luxury. Cities\\u2019 makeup prioritizes buildings rather than vast, green space in order to ensure density. But during a worldwide pandemic with shelter-in-place mandates and business closures, access to open space is a necessity for public health.\"), mdx(\"p\", null, \"By early April, 45 states in the U.S. had \", mdx(\"a\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, {\n    \"href\": \"https://www.nbcnews.com/health/health-news/here-are-stay-home-orders-across-country-n1168736\",\n    \"target\": \"_blank\",\n    \"rel\": \"noreferrer\"\n  }), \"stay-at-home orders\"), \" of varying degrees. Streets emptied, public transportation ridership decreased, and overall traffic disappeared revealing smog-less skies. The activity-void landscape from afar gave people, especially urbanists, the opportunity to rethink urban life and envision \", mdx(\"a\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, {\n    \"href\": \"https://www.nytimes.com/2020/07/09/opinion/sunday/ban-cars-manhattan-cities.html\",\n    \"target\": \"_blank\",\n    \"rel\": \"noreferrer\"\n  }), \"car-less, walkable cities\"), \". Streets became the center of attention and a canvas for new, urgent ideas. But on the ground, there were people in desperate need of space \\u2014 to walk socially distant from strangers, to exercise, and to be. And in June, Black Lives Matter movements and protests against racism and police violence filling up the empty streets brought a crucial point into the conversation: equity.\"), mdx(\"p\", null, \"Inequitable distribution of parks and public space is not news. \\u201CThe average park size is 6.4 acres in poor neighborhoods, compared with 14 acres in wealthy neighborhoods, according to an analysis by the \", mdx(\"a\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, {\n    \"href\": \"https://www.nytimes.com/2020/07/15/nyregion/nyc-parks-access-governors-island.html\",\n    \"target\": \"_blank\",\n    \"rel\": \"noreferrer\"\n  }), \"Trust for Public Land.\"), \"\\u201D Using quantitative and qualitative data, this post   shows how open space distribution in NYC fared during the pandemic.\"), mdx(\"p\", null, mdx(\"strong\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"How much space is open in NYC?\")), mdx(\"p\", null, mdx(\"span\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, {\n    \"className\": \"gatsby-resp-image-wrapper\",\n    \"style\": {\n      \"position\": \"relative\",\n      \"display\": \"block\",\n      \"marginLeft\": \"auto\",\n      \"marginRight\": \"auto\",\n      \"maxWidth\": \"2480px\"\n    }\n  }), \"\\n      \", mdx(\"span\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"span\"\n  }, {\n    \"className\": \"gatsby-resp-image-background-image\",\n    \"style\": {\n      \"paddingBottom\": \"141.45161290322582%\",\n      \"position\": \"relative\",\n      \"bottom\": \"0\",\n      \"left\": \"0\",\n      \"backgroundImage\": \"url('')\",\n      \"backgroundSize\": \"cover\",\n      \"display\": \"block\"\n    }\n  })), \"\\n  \", mdx(\"picture\", {\n    parentName: \"span\"\n  }, \"\\n        \", mdx(\"source\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"picture\"\n  }, {\n    \"srcSet\": [\"/static/2cafccf172bf6e75e82d9fec9d8de529/8e64d/map.webp 2480w\"],\n    \"sizes\": \"(max-width: 2480px) 100vw, 2480px\",\n    \"type\": \"image/webp\"\n  })), \"\\n        \", mdx(\"source\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"picture\"\n  }, {\n    \"srcSet\": [\"/static/2cafccf172bf6e75e82d9fec9d8de529/8c5c5/map.png 2480w\"],\n    \"sizes\": \"(max-width: 2480px) 100vw, 2480px\",\n    \"type\": \"image/png\"\n  })), \"\\n        \", mdx(\"img\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"picture\"\n  }, {\n    \"className\": \"gatsby-resp-image-image\",\n    \"src\": \"/static/2cafccf172bf6e75e82d9fec9d8de529/8c5c5/map.png\",\n    \"alt\": \"Map of all open spaces in NYC\",\n    \"title\": \"Map of all open spaces in NYC before the pandemic\",\n    \"loading\": \"lazy\",\n    \"style\": {\n      \"width\": \"100%\",\n      \"height\": \"100%\",\n      \"margin\": \"0\",\n      \"verticalAlign\": \"middle\",\n      \"position\": \"absolute\",\n      \"top\": \"0\",\n      \"left\": \"0\"\n    }\n  })), \"\\n      \"), \"\\n    \")), mdx(\"p\", null, \"New York City, on a pre-pandemic day, would have approximately 33,630 acres of open space, which is around 16% of total city land. Streets are considered as open spaces as well, adding 8,137 miles. What counts as open space in this map:\"), mdx(\"ul\", null, mdx(\"li\", {\n    parentName: \"ul\"\n  }, \"Parks operated by Department of Parks and Recreation\"), mdx(\"li\", {\n    parentName: \"ul\"\n  }, \"Recreational Areas not designated as NYC Parks\"), mdx(\"li\", {\n    parentName: \"ul\"\n  }, \"Department of Transportation Pedestrian Plazas\"), mdx(\"li\", {\n    parentName: \"ul\"\n  }, \"Cemeteries\"), mdx(\"li\", {\n    parentName: \"ul\"\n  }, \"Streets\")), mdx(\"p\", null, \"I use figure ground maps, which are used to show the relationship between the built environment and open space, to illustrate which spaces were open or closed and how openness evolved during the course of the past few months.\"), mdx(\"h4\", {\n    \"id\": \"how-much-was-closed-in-april\"\n  }, \"How much was closed in April?\"), mdx(\"p\", null, mdx(\"span\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, {\n    \"className\": \"gatsby-resp-image-wrapper\",\n    \"style\": {\n      \"position\": \"relative\",\n      \"display\": \"block\",\n      \"marginLeft\": \"auto\",\n      \"marginRight\": \"auto\",\n      \"maxWidth\": \"2480px\"\n    }\n  }), \"\\n      \", mdx(\"span\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"span\"\n  }, {\n    \"className\": \"gatsby-resp-image-background-image\",\n    \"style\": {\n      \"paddingBottom\": \"141.45161290322582%\",\n      \"position\": \"relative\",\n      \"bottom\": \"0\",\n      \"left\": \"0\",\n      \"backgroundImage\": \"url('')\",\n      \"backgroundSize\": \"cover\",\n      \"display\": \"block\"\n    }\n  })), \"\\n  \", mdx(\"picture\", {\n    parentName: \"span\"\n  }, \"\\n        \", mdx(\"source\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"picture\"\n  }, {\n    \"srcSet\": [\"/static/2e04eedfc196513775cc45ae59a2d86f/8e64d/maps2.webp 2480w\"],\n    \"sizes\": \"(max-width: 2480px) 100vw, 2480px\",\n    \"type\": \"image/webp\"\n  })), \"\\n        \", mdx(\"source\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"picture\"\n  }, {\n    \"srcSet\": [\"/static/2e04eedfc196513775cc45ae59a2d86f/8c5c5/maps2.png 2480w\"],\n    \"sizes\": \"(max-width: 2480px) 100vw, 2480px\",\n    \"type\": \"image/png\"\n  })), \"\\n        \", mdx(\"img\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"picture\"\n  }, {\n    \"className\": \"gatsby-resp-image-image\",\n    \"src\": \"/static/2e04eedfc196513775cc45ae59a2d86f/8c5c5/maps2.png\",\n    \"alt\": \"Map with highlights of closed spaces in April\",\n    \"title\": \"Map of closed spaces during April lockdown\",\n    \"loading\": \"lazy\",\n    \"style\": {\n      \"width\": \"100%\",\n      \"height\": \"100%\",\n      \"margin\": \"0\",\n      \"verticalAlign\": \"middle\",\n      \"position\": \"absolute\",\n      \"top\": \"0\",\n      \"left\": \"0\"\n    }\n  })), \"\\n      \"), \"\\n    \")), mdx(\"p\", null, \"Effective at 8pm on Sunday, March 22, all non-essential businesses in New York state were ordered to close along with parks with any recreational features such as playgrounds, basketball courts, and beaches. Cemeteries remained open, but closed to visitors. This meant around 30% of NYC\\u2019s open spaces were not accessible\\u2014this equates to around 12 Central Parks being closed. These closed spaces are marked red in the above map.\"), mdx(\"p\", null, \"When Covid-19 hospitalization rates were at its \", mdx(\"a\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, {\n    \"href\": \"https://www1.nyc.gov/site/doh/covid/covid-19-data.page\",\n    \"target\": \"_blank\",\n    \"rel\": \"noreferrer\"\n  }), \"peak\"), \" on 3/30 with 6,136 cases in NYC, limiting access to spaces where there are chances of people congregating in large numbers was the right move. What this closure strategy surfaced is the existing inequities in open space distribution in NYC.\"), mdx(\"p\", null, \"Even from a quick glance, you can see the unequal distribution of large open spaces, which would enable proper social distancing. Each borough has one or two large parks, such as the Bronx Park and Central Park, but this means the majority of NYC residents rely on small parks in their neighborhoods for walkable open space access. And during a lockdown, with decreased public transportation use, people need safe spaces that they can walk to more than ever.\"), mdx(\"p\", null, \"A \", mdx(\"a\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, {\n    \"href\": \"https://www.arcgis.com/apps/webappviewer/index.html?id=4d082c62efb44e56b105366fb92335b3&extent=-8287910.233%2C4941135.2385%2C-8185178.8669%2C4998463.0097%2C102100\",\n    \"target\": \"_blank\",\n    \"rel\": \"noreferrer\"\n  }), \"map\"), \" from the Trust for Public Land shows park needs in NYC during the summer of 2020, determined by access to an open park within a ten-minute walk of home. Taking findings from this map, I zoomed into a neighborhood that has a high need for parks this summer to see what the change looked like. Elmhurst in Queens saw a 64% decrease in neighborhood open space in April. And with social distancing, the remaining open space were most likely used at a lower capacity.\"), mdx(\"p\", null, mdx(\"span\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, {\n    \"className\": \"gatsby-resp-image-wrapper\",\n    \"style\": {\n      \"position\": \"relative\",\n      \"display\": \"block\",\n      \"marginLeft\": \"auto\",\n      \"marginRight\": \"auto\",\n      \"maxWidth\": \"2332px\"\n    }\n  }), \"\\n      \", mdx(\"span\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"span\"\n  }, {\n    \"className\": \"gatsby-resp-image-background-image\",\n    \"style\": {\n      \"paddingBottom\": \"76.45797598627787%\",\n      \"position\": \"relative\",\n      \"bottom\": \"0\",\n      \"left\": \"0\",\n      \"backgroundImage\": \"url('')\",\n      \"backgroundSize\": \"cover\",\n      \"display\": \"block\"\n    }\n  })), \"\\n  \", mdx(\"picture\", {\n    parentName: \"span\"\n  }, \"\\n        \", mdx(\"source\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"picture\"\n  }, {\n    \"srcSet\": [\"/static/e3764acb5faaff3af9ba942d12d89fb7/ad528/elm-copy.webp 2332w\"],\n    \"sizes\": \"(max-width: 2332px) 100vw, 2332px\",\n    \"type\": \"image/webp\"\n  })), \"\\n        \", mdx(\"source\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"picture\"\n  }, {\n    \"srcSet\": [\"/static/e3764acb5faaff3af9ba942d12d89fb7/a90b0/elm-copy.png 2332w\"],\n    \"sizes\": \"(max-width: 2332px) 100vw, 2332px\",\n    \"type\": \"image/png\"\n  })), \"\\n        \", mdx(\"img\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"picture\"\n  }, {\n    \"className\": \"gatsby-resp-image-image\",\n    \"src\": \"/static/e3764acb5faaff3af9ba942d12d89fb7/a90b0/elm-copy.png\",\n    \"alt\": \"Elmhurst, Queens\",\n    \"title\": \"Open and closed spaces in Elmhurst, Queens in April\",\n    \"loading\": \"lazy\",\n    \"style\": {\n      \"width\": \"100%\",\n      \"height\": \"100%\",\n      \"margin\": \"0\",\n      \"verticalAlign\": \"middle\",\n      \"position\": \"absolute\",\n      \"top\": \"0\",\n      \"left\": \"0\"\n    }\n  })), \"\\n      \"), \"\\n    \")), mdx(\"h4\", {\n    \"id\": \"what-about-privately-owned-public-spacespops\"\n  }, mdx(\"strong\", {\n    parentName: \"h4\"\n  }, \"What about Privately Owned Public Spaces(POPS)?\")), mdx(\"p\", null, mdx(\"span\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, {\n    \"className\": \"gatsby-resp-image-wrapper\",\n    \"style\": {\n      \"position\": \"relative\",\n      \"display\": \"block\",\n      \"marginLeft\": \"auto\",\n      \"marginRight\": \"auto\",\n      \"maxWidth\": \"2480px\"\n    }\n  }), \"\\n      \", mdx(\"span\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"span\"\n  }, {\n    \"className\": \"gatsby-resp-image-background-image\",\n    \"style\": {\n      \"paddingBottom\": \"141.45161290322582%\",\n      \"position\": \"relative\",\n      \"bottom\": \"0\",\n      \"left\": \"0\",\n      \"backgroundImage\": \"url('')\",\n      \"backgroundSize\": \"cover\",\n      \"display\": \"block\"\n    }\n  })), \"\\n  \", mdx(\"picture\", {\n    parentName: \"span\"\n  }, \"\\n        \", mdx(\"source\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"picture\"\n  }, {\n    \"srcSet\": [\"/static/9c56bf05f4dd7cd38aac77250085821c/8e64d/maps4.webp 2480w\"],\n    \"sizes\": \"(max-width: 2480px) 100vw, 2480px\",\n    \"type\": \"image/webp\"\n  })), \"\\n        \", mdx(\"source\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"picture\"\n  }, {\n    \"srcSet\": [\"/static/9c56bf05f4dd7cd38aac77250085821c/8c5c5/maps4.png 2480w\"],\n    \"sizes\": \"(max-width: 2480px) 100vw, 2480px\",\n    \"type\": \"image/png\"\n  })), \"\\n        \", mdx(\"img\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"picture\"\n  }, {\n    \"className\": \"gatsby-resp-image-image\",\n    \"src\": \"/static/9c56bf05f4dd7cd38aac77250085821c/8c5c5/maps4.png\",\n    \"alt\": \"POPS in NYC\",\n    \"title\": \"POPS in NYC\",\n    \"loading\": \"lazy\",\n    \"style\": {\n      \"width\": \"100%\",\n      \"height\": \"100%\",\n      \"margin\": \"0\",\n      \"verticalAlign\": \"middle\",\n      \"position\": \"absolute\",\n      \"top\": \"0\",\n      \"left\": \"0\"\n    }\n  })), \"\\n      \"), \"\\n    \")), mdx(\"p\", null, \"POPS is an important (and \", mdx(\"a\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, {\n    \"href\": \"https://www.nytimes.com/2017/04/19/nyregion/public-space-trump-tower.html\",\n    \"target\": \"_blank\",\n    \"rel\": \"noreferrer\"\n  }), \"controversial\"), \") addition to public space in NYC, with the first initiatives dating to the 1960s. Some are plazas in front of buildings like the Seagram building and some are parks with green space such as the Domino Park in Williamsburg. POPS are a way for the city to create more public space within private development. The map shows that the majority distribution is in Manhattan, in areas with already walkable access to Central Park or Bryant Park. It was also unclear what was open during the lockdown because unlike city parks, there was no direct way to find information about whether they were open.\"), mdx(\"p\", null, mdx(\"strong\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"\\u201COpen\\u201D Streets\")), mdx(\"p\", null, mdx(\"span\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, {\n    \"className\": \"gatsby-resp-image-wrapper\",\n    \"style\": {\n      \"position\": \"relative\",\n      \"display\": \"block\",\n      \"marginLeft\": \"auto\",\n      \"marginRight\": \"auto\",\n      \"maxWidth\": \"2480px\"\n    }\n  }), \"\\n      \", mdx(\"span\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"span\"\n  }, {\n    \"className\": \"gatsby-resp-image-background-image\",\n    \"style\": {\n      \"paddingBottom\": \"141.45161290322582%\",\n      \"position\": \"relative\",\n      \"bottom\": \"0\",\n      \"left\": \"0\",\n      \"backgroundImage\": \"url('')\",\n      \"backgroundSize\": \"cover\",\n      \"display\": \"block\"\n    }\n  })), \"\\n  \", mdx(\"picture\", {\n    parentName: \"span\"\n  }, \"\\n        \", mdx(\"source\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"picture\"\n  }, {\n    \"srcSet\": [\"/static/101eeaa3a5726b026270b2ec5157b07b/8e64d/maps3.webp 2480w\"],\n    \"sizes\": \"(max-width: 2480px) 100vw, 2480px\",\n    \"type\": \"image/webp\"\n  })), \"\\n        \", mdx(\"source\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"picture\"\n  }, {\n    \"srcSet\": [\"/static/101eeaa3a5726b026270b2ec5157b07b/8c5c5/maps3.png 2480w\"],\n    \"sizes\": \"(max-width: 2480px) 100vw, 2480px\",\n    \"type\": \"image/png\"\n  })), \"\\n        \", mdx(\"img\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"picture\"\n  }, {\n    \"className\": \"gatsby-resp-image-image\",\n    \"src\": \"/static/101eeaa3a5726b026270b2ec5157b07b/8c5c5/maps3.png\",\n    \"alt\": \"Open Streets in NYC\",\n    \"title\": \"Open Street Locations in NYC\",\n    \"loading\": \"lazy\",\n    \"style\": {\n      \"width\": \"100%\",\n      \"height\": \"100%\",\n      \"margin\": \"0\",\n      \"verticalAlign\": \"middle\",\n      \"position\": \"absolute\",\n      \"top\": \"0\",\n      \"left\": \"0\"\n    }\n  })), \"\\n      \"), \"\\n    \")), mdx(\"p\", null, \"A popular pandemic response to inadequate space for social distancing and outdoor activities is Open Streets. Oakland, Milan, and many other cities have \", mdx(\"a\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, {\n    \"href\": \"https://www.archdaily.com/938202/people-to-reclaim-streets-in-milan-in-post-covid-19-vision-of-the-city\",\n    \"target\": \"_blank\",\n    \"rel\": \"noreferrer\"\n  }), \"adopted similar strategies\"), \". Open Streets in NYC are pedestrian-friendly streets that are blocked off by NYPD barricades during daytime hours to allow for social distancing while walking and to use as pseudo-park space. A total of 67 miles have been opened up (or closed depending on how you are using the street) to date, shown as white lines in the map. This effort is combined with Open Restaurants as the city is reopening and allowing outdoor dining using parking space and sidewalk space.\"), mdx(\"p\", null, \"What the data shows on the map allows for possibilities of car-less streets and brings memories of \", mdx(\"a\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, {\n    \"href\": \"https://www1.nyc.gov/html/dot/summerstreets/html/home/home.shtml\",\n    \"target\": \"_blank\",\n    \"rel\": \"noreferrer\"\n  }), \"Summer Streets\"), \". (Summer Streets have been cancelled for 2020.) However, what the data misses is how open these designated streets are used in reality. First, there is critique about how the process\", mdx(\"a\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, {\n    \"href\": \"https://www.nytimes.com/2020/07/20/upshot/pandemic-city-planning-inequality.html\",\n    \"target\": \"_blank\",\n    \"rel\": \"noreferrer\"\n  }), \" lacks public participation\"), \". And there were \", mdx(\"a\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, {\n    \"href\": \"https://nyc.streetsblog.org/2020/05/18/nypd-inconsistent-on-actually-opening-the-mayors-open-streets/\",\n    \"target\": \"_blank\",\n    \"rel\": \"noreferrer\"\n  }), \"mixed reactions\"), \" from the public as the set up required police involvement, which delayed the process.\", mdx(\"a\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, {\n    \"href\": \"https://nyc.streetsblog.org/2020/05/18/nypd-inconsistent-on-actually-opening-the-mayors-open-streets/\",\n    \"target\": \"_blank\",\n    \"rel\": \"noreferrer\"\n  })), \" \"), mdx(\"p\", null, mdx(\"span\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, {\n    \"className\": \"gatsby-resp-image-wrapper\",\n    \"style\": {\n      \"position\": \"relative\",\n      \"display\": \"block\",\n      \"marginLeft\": \"auto\",\n      \"marginRight\": \"auto\",\n      \"maxWidth\": \"3024px\"\n    }\n  }), \"\\n      \", mdx(\"span\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"span\"\n  }, {\n    \"className\": \"gatsby-resp-image-background-image\",\n    \"style\": {\n      \"paddingBottom\": \"133.32%\",\n      \"position\": \"relative\",\n      \"bottom\": \"0\",\n      \"left\": \"0\",\n      \"backgroundImage\": \"url('')\",\n      \"backgroundSize\": \"cover\",\n      \"display\": \"block\"\n    }\n  })), \"\\n  \", mdx(\"picture\", {\n    parentName: \"span\"\n  }, \"\\n        \", mdx(\"source\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"picture\"\n  }, {\n    \"srcSet\": [\"/static/388352af743ed129d5a8b28a893830e7/a3bc4/img_6612.webp 2500w\", \"/static/388352af743ed129d5a8b28a893830e7/88d9d/img_6612.webp 3024w\"],\n    \"sizes\": \"(max-width: 3024px) 100vw, 3024px\",\n    \"type\": \"image/webp\"\n  })), \"\\n        \", mdx(\"source\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"picture\"\n  }, {\n    \"srcSet\": [\"/static/388352af743ed129d5a8b28a893830e7/412e4/img_6612.png 2500w\", \"/static/388352af743ed129d5a8b28a893830e7/2d317/img_6612.png 3024w\"],\n    \"sizes\": \"(max-width: 3024px) 100vw, 3024px\",\n    \"type\": \"image/png\"\n  })), \"\\n        \", mdx(\"img\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"picture\"\n  }, {\n    \"className\": \"gatsby-resp-image-image\",\n    \"src\": \"/static/388352af743ed129d5a8b28a893830e7/2d317/img_6612.png\",\n    \"alt\": \"Dismantled barricades on a Brooklyn street\",\n    \"title\": \"Dismantled barricades on a Brooklyn street\",\n    \"loading\": \"lazy\",\n    \"style\": {\n      \"width\": \"100%\",\n      \"height\": \"100%\",\n      \"margin\": \"0\",\n      \"verticalAlign\": \"middle\",\n      \"position\": \"absolute\",\n      \"top\": \"0\",\n      \"left\": \"0\"\n    }\n  })), \"\\n      \"), \"\\n    \")), mdx(\"p\", null, \"When a residential street in Bedford-Stuyvesant first \\u201Copened\\u201D in May, kids and families used it as a bike and skate park. Gradually, the barricades were moved to allow for car traffic and without official maintenance, the barricades never went up again. Google Maps still shows it as a pedestrian street.\"), mdx(\"p\", null, mdx(\"span\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, {\n    \"className\": \"gatsby-resp-image-wrapper\",\n    \"style\": {\n      \"position\": \"relative\",\n      \"display\": \"block\",\n      \"marginLeft\": \"auto\",\n      \"marginRight\": \"auto\",\n      \"maxWidth\": \"3024px\"\n    }\n  }), \"\\n      \", mdx(\"span\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"span\"\n  }, {\n    \"className\": \"gatsby-resp-image-background-image\",\n    \"style\": {\n      \"paddingBottom\": \"133.32%\",\n      \"position\": \"relative\",\n      \"bottom\": \"0\",\n      \"left\": \"0\",\n      \"backgroundImage\": \"url('')\",\n      \"backgroundSize\": \"cover\",\n      \"display\": \"block\"\n    }\n  })), \"\\n  \", mdx(\"picture\", {\n    parentName: \"span\"\n  }, \"\\n        \", mdx(\"source\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"picture\"\n  }, {\n    \"srcSet\": [\"/static/5a97a253a15cd568214845a2ed462edf/a3bc4/img_6674.webp 2500w\", \"/static/5a97a253a15cd568214845a2ed462edf/88d9d/img_6674.webp 3024w\"],\n    \"sizes\": \"(max-width: 3024px) 100vw, 3024px\",\n    \"type\": \"image/webp\"\n  })), \"\\n        \", mdx(\"source\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"picture\"\n  }, {\n    \"srcSet\": [\"/static/5a97a253a15cd568214845a2ed462edf/412e4/img_6674.png 2500w\", \"/static/5a97a253a15cd568214845a2ed462edf/2d317/img_6674.png 3024w\"],\n    \"sizes\": \"(max-width: 3024px) 100vw, 3024px\",\n    \"type\": \"image/png\"\n  })), \"\\n        \", mdx(\"img\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"picture\"\n  }, {\n    \"className\": \"gatsby-resp-image-image\",\n    \"src\": \"/static/5a97a253a15cd568214845a2ed462edf/2d317/img_6674.png\",\n    \"alt\": \"Berry Street July 3rd 2020\",\n    \"title\": \"Berry Street July 3rd 2020\",\n    \"loading\": \"lazy\",\n    \"style\": {\n      \"width\": \"100%\",\n      \"height\": \"100%\",\n      \"margin\": \"0\",\n      \"verticalAlign\": \"middle\",\n      \"position\": \"absolute\",\n      \"top\": \"0\",\n      \"left\": \"0\"\n    }\n  })), \"\\n      \"), \"\\n    \")), mdx(\"p\", null, \"The state of streets is another reality that interferes with the success of Open Streets as places to stay. This picture shows an empty Berry Street in Williamsburg on July 3rd, Friday at 3pm. Without much tree coverage on a hot summer day, this long strip of Open Streets is not a desirable space to spend time in.\"), mdx(\"p\", null, \"And now with businesses using the street and increased vehicle traffic compared to April, people in need of open space are being pushed once again to share the street.\"), mdx(\"h4\", {\n    \"id\": \"the-silver-lining\"\n  }, \"The Silver Lining\"), mdx(\"p\", null, \"Covid-19, of its many impacts, has taken away the joys of city living and accentuated the difficult experiences. But New Yorkers are resilient and creative. Stoop birthday parties, sidewalk ceramic studios, parklet dining color coded with the restaurant\\u2019s sign, and streets as space to demand justice. Moreover, the increased attention on reevaluating public spaces offers hope towards a healthier, more equitable, safer \\u2014 livable for all \\u2014 city.\"), mdx(\"p\", null, mdx(\"strong\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, mdx(\"iframe\", {\n    width: \"100%\",\n    height: \"520\",\n    frameBorder: \"0\",\n    src: \"https://mit.carto.com/u/laurapk/builder/e37c169c-c929-4de6-a8c5-a19f94af5319/embed\",\n    allowFullScreen: true,\n    webkitallowfullscreen: true,\n    mozallowfullscreen: true,\n    oallowfullscreen: true,\n    msallowfullscreen: true\n  }))), mdx(\"h4\", {\n    \"id\": \"data-sources\"\n  }, mdx(\"strong\", {\n    parentName: \"h4\"\n  }, \"Data Sources\")), mdx(\"p\", null, \"Department of Information Technology & Telecommunications, Open Space (Parks), 2018.\"), mdx(\"p\", null, \"Department of Information Technology & Telecommunications, Open Space (Other), 2018.\"), mdx(\"p\", null, \"Department of Transportation, NYC DOT Pedestrian Plazas, 2020.\"), mdx(\"p\", null, \"Department of Transportation, Open Streets Locations, 2020. \"), mdx(\"p\", null, \"Department of Parks and Recreation, Beaches, 2018.\"), mdx(\"p\", null, \"Department of City Planning, Privately Owned Public Space Database, 2018.\"));\n}\n;\nMDXContent.isMDXComponent = true;","hero":{"full":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":0.7065868263473054,"src":"/static/2e04eedfc196513775cc45ae59a2d86f/a1946/maps2.png","srcSet":"/static/2e04eedfc196513775cc45ae59a2d86f/5b37e/maps2.png 236w,\n/static/2e04eedfc196513775cc45ae59a2d86f/49058/maps2.png 472w,\n/static/2e04eedfc196513775cc45ae59a2d86f/a1946/maps2.png 944w,\n/static/2e04eedfc196513775cc45ae59a2d86f/030f1/maps2.png 1416w,\n/static/2e04eedfc196513775cc45ae59a2d86f/75927/maps2.png 1888w,\n/static/2e04eedfc196513775cc45ae59a2d86f/ac49a/maps2.png 2480w","srcWebp":"/static/2e04eedfc196513775cc45ae59a2d86f/99fbb/maps2.webp","srcSetWebp":"/static/2e04eedfc196513775cc45ae59a2d86f/77392/maps2.webp 236w,\n/static/2e04eedfc196513775cc45ae59a2d86f/1f177/maps2.webp 472w,\n/static/2e04eedfc196513775cc45ae59a2d86f/99fbb/maps2.webp 944w,\n/static/2e04eedfc196513775cc45ae59a2d86f/4a492/maps2.webp 1416w,\n/static/2e04eedfc196513775cc45ae59a2d86f/b0b8f/maps2.webp 1888w,\n/static/2e04eedfc196513775cc45ae59a2d86f/21b97/maps2.webp 2480w","sizes":"(max-width: 944px) 100vw, 944px"},"regular":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":0.7056277056277056,"src":"/static/2e04eedfc196513775cc45ae59a2d86f/3ddd4/maps2.png","srcSet":"/static/2e04eedfc196513775cc45ae59a2d86f/078a8/maps2.png 163w,\n/static/2e04eedfc196513775cc45ae59a2d86f/e56da/maps2.png 327w,\n/static/2e04eedfc196513775cc45ae59a2d86f/3ddd4/maps2.png 653w,\n/static/2e04eedfc196513775cc45ae59a2d86f/c5cc7/maps2.png 980w,\n/static/2e04eedfc196513775cc45ae59a2d86f/eebd2/maps2.png 1306w,\n/static/2e04eedfc196513775cc45ae59a2d86f/ac49a/maps2.png 2480w","srcWebp":"/static/2e04eedfc196513775cc45ae59a2d86f/0acdf/maps2.webp","srcSetWebp":"/static/2e04eedfc196513775cc45ae59a2d86f/ac59e/maps2.webp 163w,\n/static/2e04eedfc196513775cc45ae59a2d86f/7660b/maps2.webp 327w,\n/static/2e04eedfc196513775cc45ae59a2d86f/0acdf/maps2.webp 653w,\n/static/2e04eedfc196513775cc45ae59a2d86f/75470/maps2.webp 980w,\n/static/2e04eedfc196513775cc45ae59a2d86f/68d47/maps2.webp 1306w,\n/static/2e04eedfc196513775cc45ae59a2d86f/21b97/maps2.webp 2480w","sizes":"(max-width: 653px) 100vw, 653px"},"narrow":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":0.7080745341614907,"src":"/static/2e04eedfc196513775cc45ae59a2d86f/502b1/maps2.png","srcSet":"/static/2e04eedfc196513775cc45ae59a2d86f/f2e6d/maps2.png 114w,\n/static/2e04eedfc196513775cc45ae59a2d86f/4ddba/maps2.png 229w,\n/static/2e04eedfc196513775cc45ae59a2d86f/502b1/maps2.png 457w,\n/static/2e04eedfc196513775cc45ae59a2d86f/7ddc2/maps2.png 686w,\n/static/2e04eedfc196513775cc45ae59a2d86f/435bf/maps2.png 914w,\n/static/2e04eedfc196513775cc45ae59a2d86f/ac49a/maps2.png 2480w","srcWebp":"/static/2e04eedfc196513775cc45ae59a2d86f/15384/maps2.webp","srcSetWebp":"/static/2e04eedfc196513775cc45ae59a2d86f/31fce/maps2.webp 114w,\n/static/2e04eedfc196513775cc45ae59a2d86f/e3e25/maps2.webp 229w,\n/static/2e04eedfc196513775cc45ae59a2d86f/15384/maps2.webp 457w,\n/static/2e04eedfc196513775cc45ae59a2d86f/0258d/maps2.webp 686w,\n/static/2e04eedfc196513775cc45ae59a2d86f/64ea2/maps2.webp 914w,\n/static/2e04eedfc196513775cc45ae59a2d86f/21b97/maps2.webp 2480w","sizes":"(max-width: 457px) 100vw, 457px"},"seo":{"src":"/static/2e04eedfc196513775cc45ae59a2d86f/6050d/maps2.png"}}},"authors":[{"authorsPage":true,"bio":"Laura is a Master in City Planning candidate at MIT DUSP. She is interested in sustainable economic and environmental development in cities, specifically in urban regeneration strategies. At DUSP, she researches building energy efficiency policies and sustainable development through adaptive reuse. Before DUSP, she worked as a brand strategist, helping companies craft narratives and insight-driven, marketing strategies.","id":"dbcb6788-8efc-57a7-bb9e-63654745aa65","name":"Laura Kim","featured":false,"social":null,"slug":"/authors/laura-kim","avatar":{"small":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":0.5652173913043478,"src":"/static/20ce0c8a72ce46629552f76f7c567b5a/fa1ea/img_520704c15e76-1.jpg","srcSet":"/static/20ce0c8a72ce46629552f76f7c567b5a/afb2b/img_520704c15e76-1.jpg 13w,\n/static/20ce0c8a72ce46629552f76f7c567b5a/7c20e/img_520704c15e76-1.jpg 25w,\n/static/20ce0c8a72ce46629552f76f7c567b5a/fa1ea/img_520704c15e76-1.jpg 50w,\n/static/20ce0c8a72ce46629552f76f7c567b5a/03612/img_520704c15e76-1.jpg 75w,\n/static/20ce0c8a72ce46629552f76f7c567b5a/61cdf/img_520704c15e76-1.jpg 100w,\n/static/20ce0c8a72ce46629552f76f7c567b5a/faa31/img_520704c15e76-1.jpg 750w","srcWebp":"/static/20ce0c8a72ce46629552f76f7c567b5a/e7b2c/img_520704c15e76-1.webp","srcSetWebp":"/static/20ce0c8a72ce46629552f76f7c567b5a/58718/img_520704c15e76-1.webp 13w,\n/static/20ce0c8a72ce46629552f76f7c567b5a/74aad/img_520704c15e76-1.webp 25w,\n/static/20ce0c8a72ce46629552f76f7c567b5a/e7b2c/img_520704c15e76-1.webp 50w,\n/static/20ce0c8a72ce46629552f76f7c567b5a/ed320/img_520704c15e76-1.webp 75w,\n/static/20ce0c8a72ce46629552f76f7c567b5a/66016/img_520704c15e76-1.webp 100w,\n/static/20ce0c8a72ce46629552f76f7c567b5a/25cb1/img_520704c15e76-1.webp 750w","sizes":"(max-width: 50px) 100vw, 50px"},"medium":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":0.5681818181818182,"src":"/static/20ce0c8a72ce46629552f76f7c567b5a/61cdf/img_520704c15e76-1.jpg","srcSet":"/static/20ce0c8a72ce46629552f76f7c567b5a/7c20e/img_520704c15e76-1.jpg 25w,\n/static/20ce0c8a72ce46629552f76f7c567b5a/fa1ea/img_520704c15e76-1.jpg 50w,\n/static/20ce0c8a72ce46629552f76f7c567b5a/61cdf/img_520704c15e76-1.jpg 100w,\n/static/20ce0c8a72ce46629552f76f7c567b5a/59538/img_520704c15e76-1.jpg 150w,\n/static/20ce0c8a72ce46629552f76f7c567b5a/fd013/img_520704c15e76-1.jpg 200w,\n/static/20ce0c8a72ce46629552f76f7c567b5a/faa31/img_520704c15e76-1.jpg 750w","srcWebp":"/static/20ce0c8a72ce46629552f76f7c567b5a/66016/img_520704c15e76-1.webp","srcSetWebp":"/static/20ce0c8a72ce46629552f76f7c567b5a/74aad/img_520704c15e76-1.webp 25w,\n/static/20ce0c8a72ce46629552f76f7c567b5a/e7b2c/img_520704c15e76-1.webp 50w,\n/static/20ce0c8a72ce46629552f76f7c567b5a/66016/img_520704c15e76-1.webp 100w,\n/static/20ce0c8a72ce46629552f76f7c567b5a/d9b14/img_520704c15e76-1.webp 150w,\n/static/20ce0c8a72ce46629552f76f7c567b5a/6b183/img_520704c15e76-1.webp 200w,\n/static/20ce0c8a72ce46629552f76f7c567b5a/25cb1/img_520704c15e76-1.webp 750w","sizes":"(max-width: 100px) 100vw, 100px"},"large":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":0.5616438356164384,"src":"/static/20ce0c8a72ce46629552f76f7c567b5a/ec46e/img_520704c15e76-1.jpg","srcSet":"/static/20ce0c8a72ce46629552f76f7c567b5a/a2637/img_520704c15e76-1.jpg 82w,\n/static/20ce0c8a72ce46629552f76f7c567b5a/15203/img_520704c15e76-1.jpg 164w,\n/static/20ce0c8a72ce46629552f76f7c567b5a/ec46e/img_520704c15e76-1.jpg 328w,\n/static/20ce0c8a72ce46629552f76f7c567b5a/b69a5/img_520704c15e76-1.jpg 492w,\n/static/20ce0c8a72ce46629552f76f7c567b5a/23a36/img_520704c15e76-1.jpg 656w,\n/static/20ce0c8a72ce46629552f76f7c567b5a/faa31/img_520704c15e76-1.jpg 750w","srcWebp":"/static/20ce0c8a72ce46629552f76f7c567b5a/5a48e/img_520704c15e76-1.webp","srcSetWebp":"/static/20ce0c8a72ce46629552f76f7c567b5a/2d087/img_520704c15e76-1.webp 82w,\n/static/20ce0c8a72ce46629552f76f7c567b5a/29d87/img_520704c15e76-1.webp 164w,\n/static/20ce0c8a72ce46629552f76f7c567b5a/5a48e/img_520704c15e76-1.webp 328w,\n/static/20ce0c8a72ce46629552f76f7c567b5a/42f2e/img_520704c15e76-1.webp 492w,\n/static/20ce0c8a72ce46629552f76f7c567b5a/dec03/img_520704c15e76-1.webp 656w,\n/static/20ce0c8a72ce46629552f76f7c567b5a/25cb1/img_520704c15e76-1.webp 750w","sizes":"(max-width: 328px) 100vw, 328px"}}}],"basePath":"/","permalink":"https://blog.civicdatadesignlab.mit.edu/covid-19-open-spaces:-numbers-and-reality-in-nyc/","slug":"/covid-19-open-spaces:-numbers-and-reality-in-nyc","id":"185b6f9c-f595-5e66-b928-e44fb5be0ba4","title":"COVID-19 Open Spaces: Numbers and Reality in NYC","canonicalUrl":null,"mailchimp":"","next":[{"id":"7ade3f9c-8fac-5020-8033-ae3bf8f4aa88","slug":"/statewide-eviction-protections-visualized","secret":false,"title":"Statewide Eviction Protections, Visualized","author":"Joyce Zhao","date":"August 7th, 2020","dateForSEO":"2020-08-07T00:00:00.000Z","timeToRead":3,"excerpt":"The eviction moratorium under the Federal CARES Act came to an end recently on July 25, and many state-wide eviction protections are quickly…","canonical_url":null,"subscription":true,"body":"function _extends() { _extends = Object.assign || function (target) { for (var i = 1; i < arguments.length; i++) { var source = arguments[i]; for (var key in source) { if (Object.prototype.hasOwnProperty.call(source, key)) { target[key] = source[key]; } } } return target; }; return _extends.apply(this, arguments); }\n\nfunction _objectWithoutProperties(source, excluded) { if (source == null) return {}; var target = _objectWithoutPropertiesLoose(source, excluded); var key, i; if (Object.getOwnPropertySymbols) { var sourceSymbolKeys = Object.getOwnPropertySymbols(source); for (i = 0; i < sourceSymbolKeys.length; i++) { key = sourceSymbolKeys[i]; if (excluded.indexOf(key) >= 0) continue; if (!Object.prototype.propertyIsEnumerable.call(source, key)) continue; target[key] = source[key]; } } return target; }\n\nfunction _objectWithoutPropertiesLoose(source, excluded) { if (source == null) return {}; var target = {}; var sourceKeys = Object.keys(source); var key, i; for (i = 0; i < sourceKeys.length; i++) { key = sourceKeys[i]; if (excluded.indexOf(key) >= 0) continue; target[key] = source[key]; } return target; }\n\n/* @jsx mdx */\nvar _frontmatter = {\n  \"title\": \"Statewide Eviction Protections, Visualized\",\n  \"author\": \"Joyce Zhao\",\n  \"date\": \"2020-08-07T00:00:00.000Z\",\n  \"tags\": [\"Covid\", \"Data\"],\n  \"hero\": \"images/evictionrates.png\"\n};\n\nvar makeShortcode = function makeShortcode(name) {\n  return function MDXDefaultShortcode(props) {\n    console.warn(\"Component \" + name + \" was not imported, exported, or provided by MDXProvider as global scope\");\n    return mdx(\"div\", props);\n  };\n};\n\nvar layoutProps = {\n  _frontmatter: _frontmatter\n};\nvar MDXLayout = \"wrapper\";\nreturn function MDXContent(_ref) {\n  var components = _ref.components,\n      props = _objectWithoutProperties(_ref, [\"components\"]);\n\n  return mdx(MDXLayout, _extends({}, layoutProps, props, {\n    components: components,\n    mdxType: \"MDXLayout\"\n  }), mdx(\"p\", null, \"The eviction moratorium under the Federal CARES Act came to an end recently on July 25, and many state-wide eviction protections are quickly following. Many are worried that renters in America could be facing an unprecedented eviction crisis, with some estimating up to \", mdx(\"a\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, {\n    \"href\": \"https://www.cnbc.com/2020/07/30/what-its-like-to-be-evicted-during-the-coivd-19-pandemic.html\",\n    \"target\": \"_blank\",\n    \"rel\": \"noreferrer\"\n  }), \"40 million renters\"), \" at risk of eviction once protections end. Described using terms such as \\u201Ctsunami wave\\u201D or \\u201Cavalanche\\u201D, this predicted eviction crisis has been met with varying policies across the country.\"), mdx(\"p\", null, \"Evictions themselves are a public health issue. Like many of the pre-existing inequalities magnified by the COVID-19 pandemic, evictions tend to affect \", mdx(\"a\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, {\n    \"href\": \"https://thehill.com/blogs/congress-blog/politics/508897-a-wave-of-mass-evictions-is-inevitable-and-black-women-will-be\",\n    \"target\": \"_blank\",\n    \"rel\": \"noreferrer\"\n  }), \"communities of color\"), \", and often low-income neighborhoods, the most. Furthermore, those threatened with eviction often face \", mdx(\"a\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, {\n    \"href\": \"https://www.bu.edu/sph/2018/10/05/the-hidden-health-crisis-of-eviction/\",\n    \"target\": \"_blank\",\n    \"rel\": \"noreferrer\"\n  }), \"adverse, long-term health outcomes\"), \". Evicted tenants also face housing instability that can lead to overcrowded households and homelessness, all which put people at greater risk of COVID-19.\"), mdx(\"p\", null, \"The graph below ranks each state by eviction rate (the number of evictions per 100 rental homes in 2016) and colors each state based on the status of their COVID eviction protection policies. The word \\u201Cprotections\\u201D emphasizes the differences in policy strength between legislations. Some states have true eviction moratoriums with a grace period for rent payment, some only prevent new eviction filings, while others only have orders to prioritize essential court proceedings. I\\u2019ve limited the scope of housing policies in this visualization to those that explicitly protect tenants from eviction and are executed state-wide. The pale green color indicates whether or not these policies have expired as of July 31, 2020. The last five states in the graph had no available eviction rates.\"), mdx(\"p\", null, mdx(\"span\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, {\n    \"className\": \"gatsby-resp-image-wrapper\",\n    \"style\": {\n      \"position\": \"relative\",\n      \"display\": \"block\",\n      \"marginLeft\": \"auto\",\n      \"marginRight\": \"auto\",\n      \"maxWidth\": \"954px\"\n    }\n  }), \"\\n      \", mdx(\"span\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"span\"\n  }, {\n    \"className\": \"gatsby-resp-image-background-image\",\n    \"style\": {\n      \"paddingBottom\": \"119.916142557652%\",\n      \"position\": \"relative\",\n      \"bottom\": \"0\",\n      \"left\": \"0\",\n      \"backgroundImage\": \"url('')\",\n      \"backgroundSize\": \"cover\",\n      \"display\": \"block\"\n    }\n  })), \"\\n  \", mdx(\"picture\", {\n    parentName: \"span\"\n  }, \"\\n        \", mdx(\"source\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"picture\"\n  }, {\n    \"srcSet\": [\"/static/e5ee9357039050751fc709a1d735f2fd/c19f8/evictionrates.webp 954w\"],\n    \"sizes\": \"(max-width: 954px) 100vw, 954px\",\n    \"type\": \"image/webp\"\n  })), \"\\n        \", mdx(\"source\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"picture\"\n  }, {\n    \"srcSet\": [\"/static/e5ee9357039050751fc709a1d735f2fd/f8dd2/evictionrates.png 954w\"],\n    \"sizes\": \"(max-width: 954px) 100vw, 954px\",\n    \"type\": \"image/png\"\n  })), \"\\n        \", mdx(\"img\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"picture\"\n  }, {\n    \"className\": \"gatsby-resp-image-image\",\n    \"src\": \"/static/e5ee9357039050751fc709a1d735f2fd/f8dd2/evictionrates.png\",\n    \"alt\": \"Eviction Rates and COVID Eviction Protections\",\n    \"title\": \"Eviction Rates and COVID Eviction Protections\",\n    \"loading\": \"lazy\",\n    \"style\": {\n      \"width\": \"100%\",\n      \"height\": \"100%\",\n      \"margin\": \"0\",\n      \"verticalAlign\": \"middle\",\n      \"position\": \"absolute\",\n      \"top\": \"0\",\n      \"left\": \"0\"\n    }\n  })), \"\\n      \"), \"\\n    \")), mdx(\"p\", null, \"What is first noticeable about this graph is the sheer number of states with expired eviction protections. As of July 31, only 20 states had existing eviction protections. Of the states with no available eviction rate data, only New Jersey currently has eviction protections; North Dakota and Alaska protections have expired, while South Dakota and Arkansas did not have state-wide protections. The constant line represents the 2.34% eviction rate of the United States in 2016. Interestingly, the four states with no state-wide COVID eviction protections all have higher rates than the national average.\"), mdx(\"p\", null, \"How long do these protections last? This next visualization examines the timeline during which these eviction protections exist. The color of each date represents the number of states with eviction protections in place on that date.\"), mdx(\"p\", null, mdx(\"span\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, {\n    \"className\": \"gatsby-resp-image-wrapper\",\n    \"style\": {\n      \"position\": \"relative\",\n      \"display\": \"block\",\n      \"marginLeft\": \"auto\",\n      \"marginRight\": \"auto\",\n      \"maxWidth\": \"1275px\"\n    }\n  }), \"\\n      \", mdx(\"span\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"span\"\n  }, {\n    \"className\": \"gatsby-resp-image-background-image\",\n    \"style\": {\n      \"paddingBottom\": \"129.41176470588235%\",\n      \"position\": \"relative\",\n      \"bottom\": \"0\",\n      \"left\": \"0\",\n      \"backgroundImage\": \"url('')\",\n      \"backgroundSize\": \"cover\",\n      \"display\": \"block\"\n    }\n  })), \"\\n  \", mdx(\"picture\", {\n    parentName: \"span\"\n  }, \"\\n        \", mdx(\"source\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"picture\"\n  }, {\n    \"srcSet\": [\"/static/0998c3136274d37a8476b494f2a10539/7f2e2/eviction-moratoria-data-duration-heatmap-1-.webp 1275w\"],\n    \"sizes\": \"(max-width: 1275px) 100vw, 1275px\",\n    \"type\": \"image/webp\"\n  })), \"\\n        \", mdx(\"source\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"picture\"\n  }, {\n    \"srcSet\": [\"/static/0998c3136274d37a8476b494f2a10539/e70d7/eviction-moratoria-data-duration-heatmap-1-.png 1275w\"],\n    \"sizes\": \"(max-width: 1275px) 100vw, 1275px\",\n    \"type\": \"image/png\"\n  })), \"\\n        \", mdx(\"img\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"picture\"\n  }, {\n    \"className\": \"gatsby-resp-image-image\",\n    \"src\": \"/static/0998c3136274d37a8476b494f2a10539/e70d7/eviction-moratoria-data-duration-heatmap-1-.png\",\n    \"alt\": \"eviction moratoria data duration heatmap 1 \",\n    \"title\": \"eviction moratoria data duration heatmap 1 \",\n    \"loading\": \"lazy\",\n    \"style\": {\n      \"width\": \"100%\",\n      \"height\": \"100%\",\n      \"margin\": \"0\",\n      \"verticalAlign\": \"middle\",\n      \"position\": \"absolute\",\n      \"top\": \"0\",\n      \"left\": \"0\"\n    }\n  })), \"\\n      \"), \"\\n    \")), mdx(\"p\", null, \"On March 13, Massachusetts and North Carolina became the first states to enact eviction-related policies. A month later on April 13, all 44 states with eviction protections had enacted them. We can see states begin to pass eviction protections most rapidly during the third week of March, with many of the executive orders announcing states of emergencies signed by governors during this week including these housing protections. Gradually, we can see these protections begin to expire. When the CARES Act eviction moratorium expired on July 25, there were 23 states with ongoing protections. Four states (Delaware, Kentucky, New Jersey, and New Mexico) have protections that expire with their state\\u2019s state of emergency orders, rather than at the end of a given duration.\"), mdx(\"p\", null, \"While it is difficult to judge the effectiveness of these policies on duration alone, observing the majority of these protections end throughout the summer could offer an explanation to the coming eviction wave that many predict. The average duration of an eviction protection policy among states is 94 days. At the end of June, around half of the states had remaining eviction protections, while the national unemployment rates remained around 11%.\"), mdx(\"p\", null, \"Some of the current policies include a grace period to pay back missed rent, but none offer rent forgiveness. Based on unemployment statistics and the Census Bureau\\u2019s \", mdx(\"a\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, {\n    \"href\": \"https://www.census.gov/programs-surveys/household-pulse-survey.html\",\n    \"target\": \"_blank\",\n    \"rel\": \"noreferrer\"\n  }), \"Household Pulse Survey\"), \", researchers have created projections on what the \", mdx(\"a\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, {\n    \"href\": \"https://www.cnbc.com/2020/07/27/how-the-eviction-crisis-will-impact-each-state.html?__source=twitter%7Cmain\",\n    \"target\": \"_blank\",\n    \"rel\": \"noreferrer\"\n  }), \"coming month of evictions\"), \" could look like for renters across the country, with some states predicted to be hit harder than others. It is worth noting that eviction protections also differ across counties and cities. This leaves tenants navigating a patchwork of protections with various strengths and expiration dates.\"), mdx(\"p\", null, mdx(\"span\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, {\n    \"className\": \"gatsby-resp-image-wrapper\",\n    \"style\": {\n      \"position\": \"relative\",\n      \"display\": \"block\",\n      \"marginLeft\": \"auto\",\n      \"marginRight\": \"auto\",\n      \"maxWidth\": \"630px\"\n    }\n  }), \"\\n      \", mdx(\"span\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"span\"\n  }, {\n    \"className\": \"gatsby-resp-image-background-image\",\n    \"style\": {\n      \"paddingBottom\": \"73.49206349206348%\",\n      \"position\": \"relative\",\n      \"bottom\": \"0\",\n      \"left\": \"0\",\n      \"backgroundImage\": \"url('')\",\n      \"backgroundSize\": \"cover\",\n      \"display\": \"block\"\n    }\n  })), \"\\n  \", mdx(\"picture\", {\n    parentName: \"span\"\n  }, \"\\n        \", mdx(\"source\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"picture\"\n  }, {\n    \"srcSet\": [\"/static/716476c233d445cb22ca3653a2dcb2cd/d869c/106627776-1595444094848-20200721_nova__table_of_eviction_forecast_metrics.webp 630w\"],\n    \"sizes\": \"(max-width: 630px) 100vw, 630px\",\n    \"type\": \"image/webp\"\n  })), \"\\n        \", mdx(\"source\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"picture\"\n  }, {\n    \"srcSet\": [\"/static/716476c233d445cb22ca3653a2dcb2cd/48f8e/106627776-1595444094848-20200721_nova__table_of_eviction_forecast_metrics.png 630w\"],\n    \"sizes\": \"(max-width: 630px) 100vw, 630px\",\n    \"type\": \"image/png\"\n  })), \"\\n        \", mdx(\"img\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"picture\"\n  }, {\n    \"className\": \"gatsby-resp-image-image\",\n    \"src\": \"/static/716476c233d445cb22ca3653a2dcb2cd/48f8e/106627776-1595444094848-20200721_nova__table_of_eviction_forecast_metrics.png\",\n    \"alt\": \"106627776 1595444094848 20200721 nova  table of eviction forecast metrics\",\n    \"title\": \"106627776 1595444094848 20200721 nova  table of eviction forecast metrics\",\n    \"loading\": \"lazy\",\n    \"style\": {\n      \"width\": \"100%\",\n      \"height\": \"100%\",\n      \"margin\": \"0\",\n      \"verticalAlign\": \"middle\",\n      \"position\": \"absolute\",\n      \"top\": \"0\",\n      \"left\": \"0\"\n    }\n  })), \"\\n      \"), \"\\n    \")), mdx(\"p\", null, \"As these state-wide eviction moratoriums expire, some are questioning where the responsibility for protecting tenants lies. Many believe that it is up to Congress to enact stronger, \", mdx(\"a\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, {\n    \"href\": \"https://www.nytimes.com/2020/07/23/opinion/coronavirus-evictions-rent.html\",\n    \"target\": \"_blank\",\n    \"rel\": \"noreferrer\"\n  }), \"nation-wide eviction moratoriums\"), \", while reports of \", mdx(\"a\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, {\n    \"href\": \"https://www.latimes.com/homeless-housing/story/2020-06-18/despite-protections-landlords-attempting-to-evict-tenants-in-south-l-a-black-and-latino-neighborhoods-data-shows\",\n    \"target\": \"_blank\",\n    \"rel\": \"noreferrer\"\n  }), \"illegal self-help evictions\"), \" are leading tenants and activist groups to defend themselves. Like many other COVID-19 related policies, such as mask mandates and economic reopening, housing protections across the country do not often align in timing, strength, or jurisdiction.\"), mdx(\"p\", null, \"In this case, we might not see the effects of these eviction protections for many months, as courts gradually reopen and summons proceed. For more information on how specific cities are witnessing evictions during the pandemic, check out the \", mdx(\"a\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, {\n    \"href\": \"https://evictionlab.org/eviction-tracking/\",\n    \"target\": \"_blank\",\n    \"rel\": \"noreferrer\"\n  }), \"COVID-19 Eviction Tracking tool\"), \" created by Princeton\\u2019s Eviction Lab.\"));\n}\n;\nMDXContent.isMDXComponent = true;","hero":{"full":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":0.833922261484099,"src":"/static/e5ee9357039050751fc709a1d735f2fd/a1946/evictionrates.png","srcSet":"/static/e5ee9357039050751fc709a1d735f2fd/5b37e/evictionrates.png 236w,\n/static/e5ee9357039050751fc709a1d735f2fd/49058/evictionrates.png 472w,\n/static/e5ee9357039050751fc709a1d735f2fd/a1946/evictionrates.png 944w,\n/static/e5ee9357039050751fc709a1d735f2fd/90fe3/evictionrates.png 954w","srcWebp":"/static/e5ee9357039050751fc709a1d735f2fd/99fbb/evictionrates.webp","srcSetWebp":"/static/e5ee9357039050751fc709a1d735f2fd/77392/evictionrates.webp 236w,\n/static/e5ee9357039050751fc709a1d735f2fd/1f177/evictionrates.webp 472w,\n/static/e5ee9357039050751fc709a1d735f2fd/99fbb/evictionrates.webp 944w,\n/static/e5ee9357039050751fc709a1d735f2fd/1399b/evictionrates.webp 954w","sizes":"(max-width: 944px) 100vw, 944px"},"regular":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":0.8358974358974359,"src":"/static/e5ee9357039050751fc709a1d735f2fd/3ddd4/evictionrates.png","srcSet":"/static/e5ee9357039050751fc709a1d735f2fd/078a8/evictionrates.png 163w,\n/static/e5ee9357039050751fc709a1d735f2fd/e56da/evictionrates.png 327w,\n/static/e5ee9357039050751fc709a1d735f2fd/3ddd4/evictionrates.png 653w,\n/static/e5ee9357039050751fc709a1d735f2fd/90fe3/evictionrates.png 954w","srcWebp":"/static/e5ee9357039050751fc709a1d735f2fd/0acdf/evictionrates.webp","srcSetWebp":"/static/e5ee9357039050751fc709a1d735f2fd/ac59e/evictionrates.webp 163w,\n/static/e5ee9357039050751fc709a1d735f2fd/7660b/evictionrates.webp 327w,\n/static/e5ee9357039050751fc709a1d735f2fd/0acdf/evictionrates.webp 653w,\n/static/e5ee9357039050751fc709a1d735f2fd/1399b/evictionrates.webp 954w","sizes":"(max-width: 653px) 100vw, 653px"},"narrow":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":0.8321167883211679,"src":"/static/e5ee9357039050751fc709a1d735f2fd/502b1/evictionrates.png","srcSet":"/static/e5ee9357039050751fc709a1d735f2fd/f2e6d/evictionrates.png 114w,\n/static/e5ee9357039050751fc709a1d735f2fd/4ddba/evictionrates.png 229w,\n/static/e5ee9357039050751fc709a1d735f2fd/502b1/evictionrates.png 457w,\n/static/e5ee9357039050751fc709a1d735f2fd/7ddc2/evictionrates.png 686w,\n/static/e5ee9357039050751fc709a1d735f2fd/435bf/evictionrates.png 914w,\n/static/e5ee9357039050751fc709a1d735f2fd/90fe3/evictionrates.png 954w","srcWebp":"/static/e5ee9357039050751fc709a1d735f2fd/15384/evictionrates.webp","srcSetWebp":"/static/e5ee9357039050751fc709a1d735f2fd/31fce/evictionrates.webp 114w,\n/static/e5ee9357039050751fc709a1d735f2fd/e3e25/evictionrates.webp 229w,\n/static/e5ee9357039050751fc709a1d735f2fd/15384/evictionrates.webp 457w,\n/static/e5ee9357039050751fc709a1d735f2fd/0258d/evictionrates.webp 686w,\n/static/e5ee9357039050751fc709a1d735f2fd/64ea2/evictionrates.webp 914w,\n/static/e5ee9357039050751fc709a1d735f2fd/1399b/evictionrates.webp 954w","sizes":"(max-width: 457px) 100vw, 457px"},"seo":{"src":"/static/e5ee9357039050751fc709a1d735f2fd/90fe3/evictionrates.png"}}},{"id":"05fc4a31-394b-5eed-9975-130225fcf0e1","slug":"/data-from-reported-covid-19-tests-are-telling-an-incomplete-story:-here's-what-you-need-to-know","secret":false,"title":"Data from reported COVID-19 tests are telling an incomplete story: Here's what you need to know","author":"Brian Williams","date":"July 31st, 2020","dateForSEO":"2020-07-31T00:00:00.000Z","timeToRead":12,"excerpt":"As of July 26th, there were 4.2 million positive COVID-19 tests in the United States, however, only about 2.2 million of those cases have race data associated. ...How did we get here?","canonical_url":null,"subscription":true,"body":"function _extends() { _extends = Object.assign || function (target) { for (var i = 1; i < arguments.length; i++) { var source = arguments[i]; for (var key in source) { if (Object.prototype.hasOwnProperty.call(source, key)) { target[key] = source[key]; } } } return target; }; return _extends.apply(this, arguments); }\n\nfunction _objectWithoutProperties(source, excluded) { if (source == null) return {}; var target = _objectWithoutPropertiesLoose(source, excluded); var key, i; if (Object.getOwnPropertySymbols) { var sourceSymbolKeys = Object.getOwnPropertySymbols(source); for (i = 0; i < sourceSymbolKeys.length; i++) { key = sourceSymbolKeys[i]; if (excluded.indexOf(key) >= 0) continue; if (!Object.prototype.propertyIsEnumerable.call(source, key)) continue; target[key] = source[key]; } } return target; }\n\nfunction _objectWithoutPropertiesLoose(source, excluded) { if (source == null) return {}; var target = {}; var sourceKeys = Object.keys(source); var key, i; for (i = 0; i < sourceKeys.length; i++) { key = sourceKeys[i]; if (excluded.indexOf(key) >= 0) continue; target[key] = source[key]; } return target; }\n\n/* @jsx mdx */\nvar _frontmatter = {\n  \"title\": \"Data from reported COVID-19 tests are telling an incomplete story: Here's what you need to know\",\n  \"author\": \"Brian Williams\",\n  \"date\": \"2020-07-31T00:00:00.000Z\",\n  \"excerpt\": \"As of July 26th, there were 4.2 million positive COVID-19 tests in the United States, however, only about 2.2 million of those cases have race data associated. ...How did we get here?\",\n  \"tags\": [\"Covid\", \"Data\", \"Health\", \"Race\", \"Visualization\"],\n  \"hero\": \"images/newplot-1-.png\"\n};\n\nvar makeShortcode = function makeShortcode(name) {\n  return function MDXDefaultShortcode(props) {\n    console.warn(\"Component \" + name + \" was not imported, exported, or provided by MDXProvider as global scope\");\n    return mdx(\"div\", props);\n  };\n};\n\nvar layoutProps = {\n  _frontmatter: _frontmatter\n};\nvar MDXLayout = \"wrapper\";\nreturn function MDXContent(_ref) {\n  var components = _ref.components,\n      props = _objectWithoutProperties(_ref, [\"components\"]);\n\n  return mdx(MDXLayout, _extends({}, layoutProps, props, {\n    components: components,\n    mdxType: \"MDXLayout\"\n  }), mdx(\"p\", null, mdx(\"strong\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"Missing Racial Data in COVID-19 Reporting\")), mdx(\"p\", null, \"In the past six months, hospitals, clinics, and medical institutions across the United States have conducted millions of COVID-19 tests. The data from the tests has been made publicly available through multiple avenues for public use. \", mdx(\"a\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, {\n    \"href\": \"https://covidtracking.com/\",\n    \"target\": \"_blank\",\n    \"rel\": \"noreferrer\"\n  }), \"The Covid Tracking Project\"), \", a volunteer organization launched from \", mdx(\"em\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"The Atlantic\"), \", has collected and published metadata to accompany the testing data. One such piece of metadata: race.\"), mdx(\"p\", null, \"When analyzing the reported race data, I\\u2019ve noticed that some states report race data much more consistently and thoroughly than others. This prompted me to dig into why this is, why a testing center does or does not report race, and how the state, county, municipal, and lab policies vary with regards to collecting and reporting race information.\"), mdx(\"p\", null, \"As a part of the CDDL\\u2019s Missing Data Project, this investigation tries to tackle just that: the missing data that is inherent in reported health data. By trying to highlight this missing data, we may be able to better illuminate issues within this larger system.\"), mdx(\"h3\", {\n    \"id\": \"at-first-glance\"\n  }, mdx(\"strong\", {\n    parentName: \"h3\"\n  }, \"At First glance.\")), mdx(\"p\", null, \"Below is a graphic representing the racial breakdown of positive cases in each U.S. state and territory over time, as data is made available.\"), mdx(\"iframe\", {\n    width: \"1200\",\n    height: \"600\",\n    frameBorder: \"0\",\n    scrolling: \"no\",\n    style: {\n      \"border\": \"none\"\n    },\n    seamless: \"seamless\",\n    src: \"//plotly.com/~brianwilliams2022/13.embed?link=false\"\n  }), mdx(\"p\", null, mdx(\"strong\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"Notes:\")), mdx(\"p\", null, \"It\\u2019s an \", mdx(\"a\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, {\n    \"href\": \"http://www.plotly.com/~brianwilliams2022/13.embed?link=false\",\n    \"target\": \"_blank\",\n    \"rel\": \"noreferrer\"\n  }), \"interactive visualization\"), \"! \", mdx(\"em\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"Please click the link to view in proper dimensions.\"), \" (1) Use the options in the top right to start/pause the animation, or even select states to compare percentages over time. You can highlight one racial category (like Asian or white) and see those individual trends in the states over time. This is a very useful feature!\"), mdx(\"p\", null, \"I urge you to pay attention to the \", mdx(\"em\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"Unknown\"), \" category as percentages move over time. \", mdx(\"strong\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"Notice these states and territories in particular:\"), \" North Dakota (ND), New York (NY), Puerto Rico (PR), Texas (TX), Northern Marianas (MP), and Virgin Islands (VI). These regions do a particularly poor job in reporting race in their testing results.\"), mdx(\"p\", null, \"When investigating, I wondered \\u201CWhat\\u2019s the functional difference between the \", mdx(\"em\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"Other\"), \" designation and the\", mdx(\"em\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"Unknown\"), \"designation?\\u201D In the context of the other racial and ethnic categories: \", mdx(\"em\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"American Indian or Alaska Native, Asian, Black or African American, Latinx, Native Hawaiian or Other Pacific Islander\"), \", and \", mdx(\"em\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"White\"), \", the \", mdx(\"em\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"Other\"), \" category doesn\\u2019t give any description of value more than the \", mdx(\"em\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"Unknown\"), \" category. And in some states, reported race data seems to switch categories - from \", mdx(\"em\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"Unknown\"), \" to \", mdx(\"em\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"Other\"), \" - after a certain date. Therefore, I decided \", mdx(\"em\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"Other\"), \" will be treated as \", mdx(\"em\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"Unknown\"), \" for the purposes of this project. Regardless, it speaks to how \\u201Cmissing data\\u201D is pervasive throughout the healthcare system.\"), mdx(\"h3\", {\n    \"id\": \"the-bigger-picture\"\n  }, mdx(\"strong\", {\n    parentName: \"h3\"\n  }, \"The Bigger Picture\")), mdx(\"p\", null, \"As of July 26th, there were \", mdx(\"strong\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"4.2 million\"), \" positive COVID-19 tests in the United States, however, only about \", mdx(\"strong\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"2.2 million\"), \" of those cases have race data associated. The \", mdx(\"em\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"Other\"), \" category is purposefully \", mdx(\"strong\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"not\"), \" considered to be a race designation in this calculation because of how it differs descriptively from \", mdx(\"em\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"Multiracial\"), \". (2)\"), mdx(\"p\", null, \"In other words, for any given COVID test, you could flip a coin to determine whether the patient\\u2019s race is known. With that level of (un)certainty, I ask: what aren\\u2019t we seeing? What could all this missing racial data mean for real COVID testing results? And how is it impacting our communities?\"), mdx(\"p\", null, \"From various \", mdx(\"a\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, {\n    \"href\": \"https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/07/05/us/coronavirus-latinos-african-americans-cdc-data.html\",\n    \"target\": \"_blank\",\n    \"rel\": \"noreferrer\"\n  }), \"sources\"), \", we know that the pandemic impacts varying demographics differently, notably, disproportionately impacting Black and Latinx communities. To that end, how accurately can we create solutions or policy decisions to alleviate and support these communities with only 50% certainty of data?\"), mdx(\"p\", null, \"In the below visualization, the known percentages of cases with reported race are plotted against each state\\u2019s testing per capita. (3) The plot is animated to show how each state has progressed over time.\"), mdx(\"iframe\", {\n    width: \"1200\",\n    height: \"800\",\n    frameBorder: \"0\",\n    scrolling: \"no\",\n    style: {\n      \"border\": \"none\"\n    },\n    seamless: \"seamless\",\n    src: \"//plotly.com/~brianwilliams2022/11.embed?link=false\"\n  }), mdx(\"p\", null, mdx(\"strong\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"Notes:\")), mdx(\"p\", null, \"Another \", mdx(\"a\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, {\n    \"href\": \"https://plotly.com/~brianwilliams2022/11.embed?link=false\",\n    \"target\": \"_blank\",\n    \"rel\": \"noreferrer\"\n  }), \"interactive visualization\"), \"! \", mdx(\"em\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"Please click the link to view in proper dimensions.\"), \" Use the options in the top right to pan around the graph and select states to highlight their path over time. You can also select multiple states with Shift+Select for easy comparisons. Hover over each state bubble for more relevant data. You can press each category name to only view states of that category as well.\"), mdx(\"p\", null, \"The size of each state bubble represents its total positive tests. So a state with more cases will be represented as a larger bubble than a state with fewer cases in this visualization.\"), mdx(\"h3\", {\n    \"id\": \"categories\"\n  }, mdx(\"strong\", {\n    parentName: \"h3\"\n  }, \"Categories\")), mdx(\"p\", null, mdx(\"em\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"[\", \"Highly Impacted States, Increasing, Decreasing, and Constant]\")), mdx(\"p\", null, \"States are categorized by whether this \\u201Cknown percentage\\u201D factor has increased, decreased, or remained relatively constant from the first time data is available for that state to the latest data available. In order for a state to be considered \\u201Cincreasing,\\u201D it would need to increase by 5 or more percentage points. Similarly, \\u201Cdecreasing\\u201D states are those that decreased by 5 or more percentage points. \\u201CConstant\\u201D states are those that lie in the middle.\"), mdx(\"p\", null, \"For example, if a state\\u2019s \\u201Cknown percentage\\u201D is 69.7% on it\\u2019s earliest date and on it\\u2019s latest date it\\u2019s 85.4%, the state will be placed in the \\u201CIncreasing\\u201D category which is labeled green in the visualization.\"), mdx(\"h3\", {\n    \"id\": \"discussion\"\n  }, mdx(\"strong\", {\n    parentName: \"h3\"\n  }, \"Discussion\")), mdx(\"p\", null, \"The motivation to use testing per capita as a metric rather than absolute state population was because we thought the rate of reporting race could be affected by the total number of tests, which correlates with a state\\u2019s population. Rather, we were interested in comparing states with similar tests per capita as that could correlate better with similar testing practices.\"), mdx(\"p\", null, mdx(\"em\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"Category: Highly Impacted States\")), mdx(\"p\", null, \"We expected states with large amounts of total positive tests (states like Arizona, California, Florida, Texas, and New York) to have very low amounts of race data reported compared to other states. We suspected that as people flooded into testing locations and the states\\u2019 testing per capita increased, some aspects of the testing process would give way. As testing locations made operational decisions to keep the testing process optimized and safe for patients and medical staff, we thought patient identification would be overlooked from the strain of this increased testing density.\"), mdx(\"p\", null, \"Looking back at this, we weren\\u2019t necessarily wrong! But considering how the state bubbles fluctuate over time and how scattered they are (suggesting little correlation between reported race data and testing density), we understand there are other variables contributing to discrepancies in reported race data other than just the impact of rising testing density.\"), mdx(\"p\", null, \"Nonetheless, here are some interesting numbers:\"), mdx(\"p\", null, \"As of July 26th,\"), mdx(\"ul\", null, mdx(\"li\", {\n    parentName: \"ul\"\n  }, \"The percent of cases that have race data in those \", mdx(\"strong\", {\n    parentName: \"li\"\n  }, \"five\"), \" highly impacted states: 32.81%\"), mdx(\"li\", {\n    parentName: \"ul\"\n  }, \"The percent of cases that have race data in every state and territory: 51.75%\"), mdx(\"li\", {\n    parentName: \"ul\"\n  }, \"The percent of cases that have race data in the \", mdx(\"em\", {\n    parentName: \"li\"\n  }, \"non-vulnerable\"), \" states: 66.29%\")), mdx(\"p\", null, \"In Arizona, California, Florida, Texas, and New York, for every 3 cases, only 1 case has race data reported, but in every other region in the United States combined, 2 out of 3 cases have race data reported. Yet, when you combine these two sets, the national average moves to 1 out of 2 cases having race data reported. This means that around \", mdx(\"strong\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"half of all COVID-19 cases in the United States\"), \" are in these \", mdx(\"strong\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"five, most impacted\"), \" states.\"), mdx(\"p\", null, mdx(\"em\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"Category: Increasing - Green\")), mdx(\"p\", null, mdx(\"strong\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"Arizona (AZ)\"), \", Connecticut (CT), Delaware (DE), Georgia (GA), Illinois (IL), Louisiana (LA), Massachusetts (MA), Maryland (MD), Maine (ME), Michigan (MI), Missouri (MO), Nebraska (NE), New Hampshire (NH), New Jersey (NJ), Nevada (NV), Pennsylvania (PA), Virginia (VA), Vermont (VT), and Washington (WA) fall into this category.\"), mdx(\"p\", null, \"Generally, green should represent positive trends as these states are reporting more race data over time.\"), mdx(\"p\", null, mdx(\"em\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"Category: Decreasing - Red\")), mdx(\"p\", null, \"Alaska (AK), Alabama (AL), Arkansas (AR), Colorado (CO), District of Columbia (DC), \", mdx(\"strong\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"Florida (FL)\"), \", Hawaii (HI), Iowa (IA), Idaho (ID), Indiana (IN), Minnesota (MN), Mississippi (MS), Montana (MT), North Carolina (NC), Oklahoma (OK), Oregon (OR), Rhode Island (RI), South Carolina (SC), \", mdx(\"strong\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"Texas (TX)\"), \", Utah (UT), and Wyoming (WY) fall into this category.\"), mdx(\"p\", null, \"This is a red flag category and some concern should be shown toward data management and reporting around race from these areas as time goes on during the pandemic.\"), mdx(\"p\", null, mdx(\"em\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"Category: Constant - Neutral\")), mdx(\"p\", null, mdx(\"strong\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"California (CA)\"), \", Guam (GU), Kansas (KS), Kentucky (KY), Northern Mariana Islands (MP), North Dakota (ND), New Mexico (NM), \", mdx(\"strong\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"New York (NY)\"), \", Ohio (OH), Puerto Rico (PR), South Dakota (SD), Tennessee (TN), Virgin Islands (VI), Wisconsin (WI), and West Virginia (WV) fall into this category.\"), mdx(\"p\", null, \"Notably, North Dakota, New York, and Puerto Rico do not report \", mdx(\"strong\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"any\"), \" race data for their reported cases. This is alarming, and we need better data from these regions.\"), mdx(\"p\", null, \"Here\\u2019s a clear \", mdx(\"a\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, {\n    \"href\": \"http://www.plotly.com/~brianwilliams2022/15.embed?link=false\",\n    \"target\": \"_blank\",\n    \"rel\": \"noreferrer\"\n  }), \"visualization\"), \" of what these categories look like on a map. \", mdx(\"em\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"Please click the link to view in proper dimensions.\")), mdx(\"iframe\", {\n    width: \"1200\",\n    height: \"800\",\n    frameBorder: \"0\",\n    scrolling: \"no\",\n    style: {\n      \"border\": \"none\"\n    },\n    seamless: \"seamless\",\n    src: \"//plotly.com/~brianwilliams2022/15.embed?link=false\"\n  }), mdx(\"h3\", {\n    \"id\": \"interview-insights\"\n  }, mdx(\"strong\", {\n    parentName: \"h3\"\n  }, \"Interview Insights\")), mdx(\"p\", null, \"To get a more qualitative explanation of what is happening in the data, I sought experts and health officials to help me understand why so much race data could be missing and where in the process - from patient arrival to lab collection to data reporting - the missing link could occur. Additionally, I wanted to understand what the process of race designation is and how it is reported accurately.\"), mdx(\"p\", null, \"First, I consulted with MIT Medical Associate Medical Director & Chief of Student Health Shawn Ferullo. He explained that policies and procedures could vary greatly not only from state to state but from institution to institution. For example, Massachusetts General Hospital may have a completely different reporting protocol than MIT Medical, associated with a higher education institution, which has a much more rigidly defined community. But at the end of the day, Ferullo says, \\u201C\", mdx(\"strong\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"what is being reported is what the State mandates to be reported.\"), \"\\u201D Let\\u2019s keep this in mind.\"), mdx(\"p\", null, \"From what I gathered, this is the testing methodology at MIT Medical, broken down into three key areas:\"), mdx(\"ol\", null, mdx(\"li\", {\n    parentName: \"ol\"\n  }, \"Clinical Testing: Someone is sick or has symptoms and needs to be monitored, typically done in the office\"), mdx(\"li\", {\n    parentName: \"ol\"\n  }, \"Contact Tracing Testing: a separate waiting area for people who may have been potentially exposed to COVID-19 but may still be healthy\"), mdx(\"li\", {\n    parentName: \"ol\"\n  }, mdx(\"strong\", {\n    parentName: \"li\"\n  }, \"Asymptomatic Testing:\"), \" Outside testing booths for people who don\\u2019t have symptoms but want testing, low-risk large volume testing is performed here, most similar to the concept of \", mdx(\"em\", {\n    parentName: \"li\"\n  }, \"drive-thru\"), \" testing (4)\")), mdx(\"p\", null, \"I\\u2019m most interested in how demographic data is being organized at these pop-up sites.\"), mdx(\"p\", null, \"As Ferullo explained, since MIT Medical uses an online health record system, with demographic data already on file, race data is automatically associated with a patient\\u2019s test, positive or negative. And in practice, this system minimizes the risk of losses of qualitative data even in the presence of high testing stress.\"), mdx(\"p\", null, \"He leaves this closing remark:\"), mdx(\"p\", null, \"\\u201CAs a clinician, so much of the day to day work is so patient-focused, as you can imagine\\u2026 The lab has whatever requirements it has to submit, so a lot of clinicians on the front lines may not even know what data is reported\\u2026 because they\\u2019re tasked with seeing the patient, collecting the test, and all of that. More of these bigger, drive up, population-based testing sites, I wonder how many are scrambling, quite honestly, if some states are just scrambling to get testing that they\\u2019re not as thoughtful with how they are setting up their systems\", \"[\", \"for data collecting]. I hate to think about how many states just don\\u2019t want to know or are intentionally not asking the question\\u201D\", \"[\", \"about race].\"), mdx(\"p\", null, \"Next, an excerpt from an interview with Sarita Shah, who is an epidemiologist at Emory University, studying racial disparities in areas with high rates of COVID-19 and volunteering with Fulton County\\u2019s health department. Notably, Shah sees the data collection problem firsthand. After doing nasal swabs at a drive-up testing site, she later calls those who test positive to fill in personal information, including race. \", mdx(\"strong\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"[\", \"self-identification]\"), \" However, even after multiple attempts, the team reaches only about half of these people. Shah says she\\u2019d love to note a person\\u2019s race when they\\u2019re sitting in front of her at the test site, but so far, the forms provided by labs that process the samples don\\u2019t have a place to note it. \\u201CI wish it was something more complex than that,\\u201D she says, \\u201Cbut it\\u2019s not.\\u201D \", mdx(\"strong\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"[\", \"the researcher also lacks an opportunity to identify patients and race data is lost]\"), \" \", \"[\", \"3]\"), mdx(\"p\", null, \"Her experience is not in isolation. Shortly after the interview with Ferullo, I followed up with MIT Medical Lab Director Jonathan Pelletier who confirmed that the template form used at MIT Medical to report testing results - sent directly from the Massachusetts Department of Public Health - has no column or option for reporting race designations. This is especially confusing because the previous data suggests Massachusetts is one of the leading states in which race data is being reported. It raises the question of how this is even possible? And where are they getting their data from if it\\u2019s not required, as Massachusetts historically has done a good job with their race data reporting. But these questions and many more, I do not have the answers to and as I leave them unexplored, I assume other laboratories across the nation are facing similar data issues.\"), mdx(\"p\", null, \"But maybe there\\u2019s hope; an amendment to the Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security (CARES) Act passed back on June 4th will require laboratories to include relevant demographic data, such as age and race, on every test. \", \"[\", \"5] However, this is scheduled to go into effect on August 1st, leaving many passionate researchers and relief organizations in the dark about this crucial piece of metadata. I guess we\\u2019ll have to wait and see if this makes a difference in the data.\"), mdx(\"h3\", {\n    \"id\": \"conclusions\"\n  }, mdx(\"strong\", {\n    parentName: \"h3\"\n  }, \"Conclusions\")), mdx(\"p\", null, \"I believe the lack of normalized and uniform systems of reporting demographic data at the local level - individual laboratories, medical institutions, testing locations, communities, and counties - results in these large discrepancies that we see at the state and national level when researchers try to draw conclusions from data aggregates. This needs to change, and fast.\"), mdx(\"p\", null, \"\\u201COne problem that epidemiologists, in particular, have seen with all of this new lab testing sites data (pharmacies, drive-throughs, non-traditional lab settings) is incomplete data,\\u201D Scott Becker of the Association of Public Health Laboratories wrote in an email to NPR. And public health experts say what\\u2019s been needed are detailed breakdowns on how the virus is affecting Black and other marginalized communities. These groups have been hit especially hard, suffering higher case numbers per capita, serious illness, hospitalizations, and death.\\u201D \", \"[\", \"2]\"), mdx(\"p\", null, \"Lastly, accurate information on race is critical in making policy decisions, particularly for civil rights and federal programs like unemployment stimulus packages and eviction moratoriums. Race data is also used to promote equal employment opportunities and to assess racial disparities in health and environmental risks. \", \"[\", \"1] And in this case, laboratory testing data, in conjunction with case reports and other demographic data, provide vital guidance for mitigation and control activities, as well as properly allocating resources for relief. \", \"[\", \"5]\"), mdx(\"p\", null, \"As the country begins to reopen its doors, access to clear and accurate data is essential to communities and leadership as they make data-driven decisions for a phased reopening. For individuals, access to clear representations of real-world data improves feelings of safety, security, and awareness, and even empowers them to take action to support themselves, their families, and their communities. I hope we are able to see real change soon.\"), mdx(\"p\", null, mdx(\"strong\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"Project Notes - Methodology\")), mdx(\"p\", null, \"(1) On some days, a state\\u2019s percentages may add up to more than 100%, we understand these to be inaccuracies in the original data set of which the visualization was made. This could be attributed to either compiling errors or reporting errors from the individual medical institutions\", \"[\", \"labs].\"), mdx(\"p\", null, \"(2) For the purposes of this project, we considered the race designation \", mdx(\"em\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"Other\"), \" to be functionally the same as \", mdx(\"em\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"Unknown\"), \" and therefore we included all cases reported having a race of \", mdx(\"em\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"Other\"), \" as unknown. We carry over this adjustment in all calculations made for unknown visualizations.\"), mdx(\"p\", null, \"This first suggestion came about after some manually screening of the CSV file used to generate the visualizations showed some interesting patterns in data management which in shorter words, looked like some cases originally designated as \", mdx(\"em\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"Unknown\"), \" were swapped over to the \", mdx(\"em\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"Other\"), \" category. As the running totals continued in the spreadsheet, it seemed suspicious and we think this is a better way to account for that uncertainty.\"), mdx(\"p\", null, \"For instance, on May 13th in Iowa, 2878 cases are reported as \", mdx(\"em\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"Unknown\"), \" and 232 cases as \", mdx(\"em\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"Other\"), \", then on May 17th, 3144 cases are now reported as \", mdx(\"em\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"Other\"), \" and 0 cases as \", mdx(\"em\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"Unknown\"), \", and from this moment forward, case numbers increase in the \", mdx(\"em\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"Other\"), \" category but remain stagnant in the \", mdx(\"em\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"Unknown\"), \" category until June 17th. This is only noticeable because of how large a change it is but would be virtually undetectable if an individual laboratory chose to reinterpret data in this way. This seems more like a shift in data management rather than real testing results, and it\\u2019s these shifts that are most interesting to us as we try to interpret the gaps in the data.\"), mdx(\"p\", null, \"(3) What does testing per capita mean?\"), mdx(\"p\", null, \"After much deliberation, we choose to map the \\u201Cknown percentages\\u201D - the percent of positive cases in which race data exists - to testing per capita instead of positive tests because of some confounding variables. Testing per capita represents the total amount of tests performed in that state by the date specified divided by the state\\u2019s population. In short, we were looking for a good way to visualize magnitudes of uncertainty as states increase their number of tests. Do testing strategies change (per state, per district, per county?) as testing density increases, especially looking at race and ethnicity data?\"), mdx(\"p\", null, \"Generally speaking, the rate of infection of a disease multiplied by the total number of tests, should result in the total number of positive tests. Therefore, inherent differences in the rate of infection in separate states may impact positive test results without increasing the total number of tests - a confounding variable that made using total positive tests undesirable.\"), mdx(\"p\", null, \"And by using raw positive tests as an axis label, we would be assuming that increases in testing density are the only cause of increases in positive tests, when this may not be valid; the rate of infection also matters. There are many social regulations and restrictions in states, such as mask mandates or general climate patterns, which can impact the rate of infection. Especially considering the timing of this legislation varies greatly from state to state. Therefore, we thought testing per capita would be a more normalized metric off which to make conclusions.\"), mdx(\"p\", null, \"(4) Drive-thru refers to making tests more available in communities in an easier way, which would increase the volume of testing. With drive-thru testing, it is easier to keep patients social distancing by staying in their vehicles and to preserve clinician PPE.\"), mdx(\"p\", null, mdx(\"strong\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"Sources\")), mdx(\"p\", null, mdx(\"em\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"Non-Data\")), mdx(\"p\", null, \"[\", \"1] \", mdx(\"a\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, {\n    \"href\": \"https://www.census.gov/topics/population/race/about.html\",\n    \"target\": \"_blank\",\n    \"rel\": \"noreferrer\"\n  }), \"US Census - About Race\")), mdx(\"p\", null, \"[\", \"2] \", mdx(\"a\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, {\n    \"href\": \"https://www.npr.org/sections/coronavirus-live-updates/2020/06/04/869815033/race-ethnicity-data-to-be-required-with-coronavirus-tests-in-u-s\",\n    \"target\": \"_blank\",\n    \"rel\": \"noreferrer\"\n  }), \"Race, Ethnicity Data To Be Required With Coronavirus Tests In U.S.\")), mdx(\"p\", null, \"[\", \"3] \", mdx(\"a\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, {\n    \"href\": \"https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2020/07/huge-hole-covid-19-testing-data-makes-it-harder-study-racial-disparities\",\n    \"target\": \"_blank\",\n    \"rel\": \"noreferrer\"\n  }), \"\\u2018Huge hole\\u2019 in COVID-19 testing data makes it harder to study racial disparities\")), mdx(\"p\", null, \"[\", \"4] \", mdx(\"a\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, {\n    \"href\": \"https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/07/05/us/coronavirus-latinos-african-americans-cdc-data.html\",\n    \"target\": \"_blank\",\n    \"rel\": \"noreferrer\"\n  }), \"The Fullest Look Yet at the Racial Inequity of Coronavirus\")), mdx(\"p\", null, \"[\", \"5] \", mdx(\"a\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, {\n    \"href\": \"https://www.hhs.gov/sites/default/files/covid-19-laboratory-data-reporting-guidance.pdf\",\n    \"target\": \"_blank\",\n    \"rel\": \"noreferrer\"\n  }), \"CARES Act Section 18115\")), mdx(\"p\", null, mdx(\"em\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"Data\")), mdx(\"p\", null, \"[\", \"6] \", mdx(\"a\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, {\n    \"href\": \"https://covidtracking.com/\",\n    \"target\": \"_blank\",\n    \"rel\": \"noreferrer\"\n  }), \"The COVID Tracking Project | The COVID Tracking Project\")), mdx(\"ul\", null, mdx(\"li\", {\n    parentName: \"ul\"\n  }, \"For raw case data.\")), mdx(\"p\", null, mdx(\"em\", {\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, \"For region populations\")), mdx(\"p\", null, \"[\", \"7] \", mdx(\"a\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, {\n    \"href\": \"https://www.census.gov/newsroom/press-kits/2019/national-state-estimates.html\",\n    \"target\": \"_blank\",\n    \"rel\": \"noreferrer\"\n  }), \"2019 National and State Population Estimates\")), mdx(\"p\", null, \"[\", \"8] \", mdx(\"a\", _extends({\n    parentName: \"p\"\n  }, {\n    \"href\": \"https://www.doi.gov/oia/islands\",\n    \"target\": \"_blank\",\n    \"rel\": \"noreferrer\"\n  }), \"Islands We Serve | US Department of the Interior\")), mdx(\"ul\", null, mdx(\"li\", {\n    parentName: \"ul\"\n  }, \"American Samoa, Guam, Northern Mariana Islands, Virgin Islands.\")));\n}\n;\nMDXContent.isMDXComponent = true;","hero":{"full":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.6164383561643836,"src":"/static/72f894d715c13b9ef93159efcc4674b8/a1946/newplot-1-.png","srcSet":"/static/72f894d715c13b9ef93159efcc4674b8/5b37e/newplot-1-.png 236w,\n/static/72f894d715c13b9ef93159efcc4674b8/49058/newplot-1-.png 472w,\n/static/72f894d715c13b9ef93159efcc4674b8/a1946/newplot-1-.png 944w,\n/static/72f894d715c13b9ef93159efcc4674b8/7f6e0/newplot-1-.png 1154w","srcWebp":"/static/72f894d715c13b9ef93159efcc4674b8/99fbb/newplot-1-.webp","srcSetWebp":"/static/72f894d715c13b9ef93159efcc4674b8/77392/newplot-1-.webp 236w,\n/static/72f894d715c13b9ef93159efcc4674b8/1f177/newplot-1-.webp 472w,\n/static/72f894d715c13b9ef93159efcc4674b8/99fbb/newplot-1-.webp 944w,\n/static/72f894d715c13b9ef93159efcc4674b8/9ba5f/newplot-1-.webp 1154w","sizes":"(max-width: 944px) 100vw, 944px"},"regular":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.613861386138614,"src":"/static/72f894d715c13b9ef93159efcc4674b8/3ddd4/newplot-1-.png","srcSet":"/static/72f894d715c13b9ef93159efcc4674b8/078a8/newplot-1-.png 163w,\n/static/72f894d715c13b9ef93159efcc4674b8/e56da/newplot-1-.png 327w,\n/static/72f894d715c13b9ef93159efcc4674b8/3ddd4/newplot-1-.png 653w,\n/static/72f894d715c13b9ef93159efcc4674b8/c5cc7/newplot-1-.png 980w,\n/static/72f894d715c13b9ef93159efcc4674b8/7f6e0/newplot-1-.png 1154w","srcWebp":"/static/72f894d715c13b9ef93159efcc4674b8/0acdf/newplot-1-.webp","srcSetWebp":"/static/72f894d715c13b9ef93159efcc4674b8/ac59e/newplot-1-.webp 163w,\n/static/72f894d715c13b9ef93159efcc4674b8/7660b/newplot-1-.webp 327w,\n/static/72f894d715c13b9ef93159efcc4674b8/0acdf/newplot-1-.webp 653w,\n/static/72f894d715c13b9ef93159efcc4674b8/75470/newplot-1-.webp 980w,\n/static/72f894d715c13b9ef93159efcc4674b8/9ba5f/newplot-1-.webp 1154w","sizes":"(max-width: 653px) 100vw, 653px"},"narrow":{"base64":"","aspectRatio":1.6056338028169015,"src":"/static/72f894d715c13b9ef93159efcc4674b8/502b1/newplot-1-.png","srcSet":"/static/72f894d715c13b9ef93159efcc4674b8/f2e6d/newplot-1-.png 114w,\n/static/72f894d715c13b9ef93159efcc4674b8/4ddba/newplot-1-.png 229w,\n/static/72f894d715c13b9ef93159efcc4674b8/502b1/newplot-1-.png 457w,\n/static/72f894d715c13b9ef93159efcc4674b8/7ddc2/newplot-1-.png 686w,\n/static/72f894d715c13b9ef93159efcc4674b8/435bf/newplot-1-.png 914w,\n/static/72f894d715c13b9ef93159efcc4674b8/7f6e0/newplot-1-.png 1154w","srcWebp":"/static/72f894d715c13b9ef93159efcc4674b8/15384/newplot-1-.webp","srcSetWebp":"/static/72f894d715c13b9ef93159efcc4674b8/31fce/newplot-1-.webp 114w,\n/static/72f894d715c13b9ef93159efcc4674b8/e3e25/newplot-1-.webp 229w,\n/static/72f894d715c13b9ef93159efcc4674b8/15384/newplot-1-.webp 457w,\n/static/72f894d715c13b9ef93159efcc4674b8/0258d/newplot-1-.webp 686w,\n/static/72f894d715c13b9ef93159efcc4674b8/64ea2/newplot-1-.webp 914w,\n/static/72f894d715c13b9ef93159efcc4674b8/9ba5f/newplot-1-.webp 1154w","sizes":"(max-width: 457px) 100vw, 457px"},"seo":{"src":"/static/72f894d715c13b9ef93159efcc4674b8/7f6e0/newplot-1-.png"}}}]}}}